U.S. Anti-Doping Agency (USADA)

Click here for the Athlete Connect application

USADA logo with registered symbol.

Global DRO logo in whiteSearch Medications & Ingredients

Close this search box.

Case Studies and Arbitration Decisions

While some athletes use dietary supplements without any problems, there are many examples of athletes who tested positive from a supplement or suffered health problems from a contaminated supplement. As the below videos and case studies reveal, the decision to use dietary supplements should not be taken lightly.

Supplement safety is never guaranteed.

Abby Raymond was just 14 years old when she was offered a protein powder and a pre-workout supplement from a family friend, who explained that his company’s products were plant-based, vegan, and made from all-natural ingredients. While excited about her first sponsorship offer, Abby’s father pointed out that Abby was subject to anti-doping rules as a standout athlete competing in sanctioned weightlifting events…a concern that was met with assurances by the company owner that his supplements were safe. After just weeks of using the supplements, Abby had an anti-doping test and soon learned that there are no guarantees when it comes to the safety of supplements.

She tested positive for ostarine, which an investigation revealed came from one of the supplements she was using that had been contaminated during the manufacturing process. Abby subsequently accepted a three-month period of ineligibility that was reduced due to her age and reliance on trusted support personnel in using the supplement.

They key takeaways from this case include:

  1. Even if labels don’t list prohibited ingredients, they may be intentionally or unintentionally contaminated with prohibited, harmful, and/or illegal ingredients.
  2. All-natural supplements aren’t a guarantee of safety.
  3. Supplements aren’t regulated like medications, so they aren’t tested for purity or efficacy before reaching consumers.

Some risks are easy to spot, some aren't.

Flavia Oliveira, a cyclist licensed by USA Cycling and the UCI, suffered from allergies and medications that caused her to feel fatigued, which led her to purchase a dietary supplement called “Hyperdrive 3.0” from an online store. She was later tested during the Giro del Trentino Donner in Italy and tested positive for oxilofrine, a stimulant on the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) Prohibited List. In her resulting case, Flavia testified that she checked the ingredients of the supplement to make sure they were not prohibited. When her first bottle ran out, she ordered a second bottle. The independent arbitrator with the American Arbitration Association (AAA) for Sport decided that it was likely the oxilofrine in her system was a result of her consumption of a supplement product.

There were several things about this case that are important:  

  1. The product Flavia was using was marketed as a stimulant/energy product. Stimulants are a category of prohibited substances on the WADA Prohibited List, which should have been a warning sign.
  1. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a public warning about the product around five months before Flavia’s positive test. Even though the FDA knew there were problems with the product, many athletes remained unaware of the problem, and Hyperdrive continued to be available for sale (the FDA cannot remove products from the market quickly). Athletes should remember that just because a product is available for sale doesn’t mean it’s safe, legal, or free of prohibited substances.
  1. The substance that caused the positive test was referred to as oxilofrine on the WADA Prohibited List, but was listed by its synonym, “methylsynephrine,” on the supplement label. It’s important to realize that comparing a supplement label to the WADA Prohibited List won’t always produce an exact match or reliable results, even when there are prohibited ingredients in the product and/or on the label.

Even convenience stores, gas stations, grocery stores, and other familiar places sell risky products.

A track and field athlete, LaShawn Merritt tested positive for an anabolic agent, called DHEA, that is prohibited at all times. USADA and a panel of independent arbitrators from the AAA agreed with Merritt that his positive test was most likely the result of ingesting a product called “Extenz” purchased from a 7-Eleven store that was legally selling the product. Merritt was very surprised that it was possible to test positive for an anabolic agent from a product purchased at a 7-Eleven. Despite his accidental ingestion of DHEA, Merritt received a 21-month period of ineligibility, which included a minimal three-month reduction from the maximum sanction.

Here are some takeaways from this case:

  1. There may be prohibited substances and harmful ingredients in products purchased from familiar retail locations, including grocery stores, corner gas stations, or convenience stores.
  1. Even in the off-season, athletes cannot let down their guard and forget about anti-doping rules. It is important to always be vigilant of what coming into contact with your body.
  1. Even if consuming a prohibited substance is an accident, you may still face a period of ineligibility and loss of results under the WADA Code.
Scroll to Top


My name is Abby Raymond and I’m a 15 year old U.S. Olympic Weightlifter, and I used to be a gymnast, so when I stopped doing that I got into Crossfit, and then Crossfit is what took me to weightlifting. I really wanted to pursue weightlifting at an elite level because I just loved everything about it and I had that gut feeling that it was what I was supposed to be doing. When I started competing at the elite level, supplements were a part of my nutrition plan. I took a protein powder and a pre-workout. I got in touch with a family friend because they had just started their own supplement company, and they introduced me to their products and asked if I wanted to try it. And me and my dad even explained to them that I was randomly drug tested by USADA, and they kind of laughed and just shook it off and said I would have nothing to worry about with their products. At the time, I knew that there was always a risk with using supplements, but because I was guaranteed that I wouldn’t have a problem with their products, I thought it would be O.K. to use.

About three weeks after I started using the products, I was drug tested for the first time. USADA came to my house after I got done working out, and I was kind of excited but a little nervous too, because I didn’t really know what to expect, but, then again, I felt kind of honored that they wanted to test me. And then I just went on training for a couple weeks after, because I was training for the American Open. And I ended up going there and I had a really good meet. I think I went five for six and broke two American records, so I was pretty excited, and I took second, overall.

But then, the day after I competed, I got a call from USADA saying that I tested positive for a drug called Ostarine. And I was really, really confused when I first heard that. And I didn’t really know what I should have been feeling. And my family was really confused, too. It was just a whole bunch of, like, chaos, I guess. I don’t know, because we didn’t know where we should go from here. And I remember I just cried that whole night, because I couldn’t believe that this had happened and I didn’t know how it had happened. And I just kept asking the questions over and over again, like, how and why. And then we got the products I was taking tested, and when they came back positive, it was really difficult to hear that. We called the owners right away. Even the owners, they didn’t know where it was being made, where it happened. So I think it was just an accident for everybody. Knowing that the supplement that was contaminated came from somebody that I trusted, it showed me that even if you trust the person, you can’t always trust the product.

I started to accept the situation more and I made peace with it, almost. Like it happened and I’m a strong believer that things happen for a reason. And I didn’t know the reason at the time, I think this is the reason now, so I can help other people and help them not to make the same mistake I did.